This two-reeler was released in 1930 and was the first of that season. It starred Bobby 'Wheezer' Huchins (1925 - 1945), Allen 'Farina' Hoskins (1920 - 1980), Jackie Cooper (b. 1922), Norman 'Chubby' Chaney (1914 - 1936), Dorothy ' Little Echo' DeBorba (1925 - 2010), and others. As soon as I saw the first scene, I remembered the movie, even though it has been years since I had seen it last.
As the story starts, the gang is playing in their makeshift playground, which was probably a work area on the Roach Studio lot. Five year old Dorothy comes out in a clean dress with her hair in lovely curls and heads straight for the mud puddle to jump in. This was a running joke in a 20 minute film that was much more complex than you would think possible in such a short amount of time. When I met Dorothy many years later at a Sons of the Desert banquet, she recanted her recollection of that movie for us! Sadly we lost Dorothy in June last year at 85 years old.
There are two stories at work in Pups is Pups. Wheezer has five puppies that he trained to come at the sound of a bell. The rest of the gang are readying their pets to take them to a fancy dog and pet show in the city, where Farina has secured a job as a page (including a uniform with brass buttons).
We follow Wheezer who has let his puppies get away. They are attracted to every bell they hear...an ambulance, an ice cream cart, a train crossing, whatever...and Wheezer can't keep up. Meanwhile, the gang arrives at the pet show where they are not allowed in. They sneak in anyway and wreak havoc, as you can imagine.
Wheezer is eventually reunited with his puppies in a scene that actually brought tears to my eyes! He looks like he was genuinely attached to those little guys. Of course he was only about five years old so that is not beyond a reasonable assumption. And the gang is back at their play area, as Dorothy takes a final plunge in the puddle.
I decided to look up Pups is Pups in one of my books. I bought Our Gang, The Life and Times of the Little Rascals many years ago. It was written by Leonard Maltin and Richard Bann in 1977. Even my books are getting old!
I had the pleasure of meeting Dick Bann in the 1980s, and he autographed my book. It is interesting to note that this book, a paperback edition, has the price of $5.95 on the back. You can't buy a paperback of this quality and content for anywhere near that as of this writing! The 1984 printing of the book (with the red cover) is still available, and the newest version from 1992 is called The Little Rascals, The Life and Times of Our Gang. If you love Hal Roach's Rascals as I do, it should be in your collection. The film descriptions and biographies, as well as the well researched insight by the authors, make this a 'must have' book.
In the book, it is mentioned that Pups is Pups was the first Our Gang comedy to have a full musical score. The music of Leroy Shield and Marvin Hatley has become synonymous with many Hal Roach comedies, including Laurel and Hardy and Charley Chase films, and is instantly recognizable.
There is even mention in the book of something that struck me as quite progressive for the early depression years. In the Our Gang comedies, we see children of several races, all playing together with total disregard for the color of their skin. Maltin and Bann go into some detail in the book about this, including comments from Farina Hoskins to back them up.
Pups is Pups appears to be available on some Our Gang DVD collections, and it is usually better to have a collection than just one film from a series. A word of warning, shy away from any colorized versions. Adding color does absolutely nothing for these movies. It should be against the law, actually.
Sunday, February 20, 2011 update: I received the comment below from Richard Bann on Facebook yesterday. Thanks again, Dick, for your knowledge and willingness to share.
If you are a member of Facebook, check out Dick's 'Notes' page for a very interesting piece on The Treasure of the Sierra Madre (1948), as mentioned below. (And buy his books!!!)
"Very nice, Allen, thanks. Vivendi is now re-releasing the Our Gang DVDs, a few at a time, until they are all for sale as individual DVDs. Not a boxed set this time. They are re-mastering the titles where they mistakenly worked from 16mm Blackhawk release prints....Whenever I drive to Paramount, I go right by the church where they filmed the closing scenes for PUPS IS PUPS...If you read the program notes for TREASURE OF THE SIERRA MADRE which I posted on FB yesterday (written for that other Hefner) there is a pretty good story about Bad-Brained Bobby Blake, still making all the wrong kind of news."